
Bilbo Why Shouldn't I Keep It
Also called: After All, Why Not? Why Shouldn't I Keep It?
- Film or TV still
- Multi-panel story
- 2 panels
What it looks like
Two stacked close-ups from The Lord of the Rings: Ian Holm as an elderly Bilbo Baggins, with curly gray hair and a red waistcoat, looks down at a small gold ring between his fingers. Top: he smiles softly. Bottom: he purses his lips into a stubborn, possessive frown.
How it's used
For clinging to something you should probably give up. The top shows the thing or the excuse, and the bottom is Bilbo's possessive turn, often captioned 'why shouldn't I keep it?', for hoarding, borrowing forever or holding a grudge.
- top panel: the thing you're tempted to keep, or 'after all, why not?'
- bottom panel: the stubborn decision, like 'why shouldn't I keep it?'
Example
- Top panel: the thing you're tempted to keep, or 'after all, why not?'
- Me after borrowing my sister's hoodie
- Bottom panel: the stubborn decision, like 'why shouldn't I keep it?'
- Why shouldn't I keep it?
- Top panel: the thing you're tempted to keep, or 'after all, why not?'
- The pen I borrowed in the meeting
- Bottom panel: the stubborn decision, like 'why shouldn't I keep it?'
- After all, why not? Why shouldn't I keep it?
Where it comes from
Ian Holm as Bilbo Baggins in The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring (2001), unwilling to give up the Ring.
Get the template
More examples: search Know Your Meme · Google Images
How people describe it
- old hobbit smiling then frowning at the ring in his hand
- bilbo staring at the ring and deciding to keep it
- old man with curly gray hair looking at a ring possessively
- lord of the rings hobbit getting greedy over a gold ring
- elderly man smiles at something in his fingers then pouts stubbornly
Not the one you meant? Describe it another way.



