Shelf & Screen

What it's like

Moodtensecreepy
Pacesteadily paced
Themesmental healthguilt and punishmentconspiracies
Stylean unreliable narratora big twista single confined location
Settingthe 1950s and 60sNew Englandislands
Genremysteriespsychological thrillers

Hand-picked next reads

If you liked Shutter Island, try these. Each one says what it shares with Shutter Island and how it differs.

  1. Film Shutter Island Martin Scorsese · 2010

    Scorsese leans into the paranoia and noir texture, with DiCaprio at his most haunted.

  2. Book Rebecca Daphne du Maurier · 1938

    An older house-bound mystery where a haunted mind and an uncanny setting pull at the reader.

  3. Book The Silent Patient Alex Michaelides · 2019

    A therapy-centered mystery with a mute patient and a twist, slighter but just as hungry for surprise.

More with the same DNA

Matched on the traits that make Shutter Island distinctive, across books and films.

  1. Book In a Dark, Dark Wood Ruth Ware · 2015

    Shares a single confined location, psychological thrillers and guilt and punishment.

  2. Film Psycho Alfred Hitchcock · 1960

    Shares psychological thrillers, mental health and a big twist.

  3. Book A Head Full of Ghosts Paul Tremblay · 2015

    Shares an unreliable narrator, psychological thrillers and New England.

  4. Film Repulsion Roman Polanski · 1965

    Shares a single confined location, psychological thrillers and mental health.

  5. Book And Then There Were None Agatha Christie · 1939

    Shares islands, a single confined location and guilt and punishment.

  6. Book The Secret History Donna Tartt · 1992

    Shares an unreliable narrator, psychological thrillers and New England.

  7. Film Black Swan Darren Aronofsky · 2010

    Shares an unreliable narrator, psychological thrillers and mental health.

  8. Film Gone Girl David Fincher · 2014

    Shares an unreliable narrator, psychological thrillers and a big twist.

Find it: Open Library