Shelf & Screen

What it's like

Mooddarktensecreepy
Pacesteadily paced
Themestrauma and recoverymental healthguilt and punishmentconspiracies
Stylean unreliable narratora big twistthick atmosphere
Settingthe 1950s and 60sNew Englandislands
Genremysteriesnoirpsychological thrillers

Hand-picked next watches

If you liked Shutter Island, try these. Each one says what it shares with Shutter Island and how it differs.

  1. Book Shutter Island Dennis Lehane · 2003

    The novel behind it, with the dread built more slowly and the final turn hitting harder on the page.

  2. Film Memento Christopher Nolan · 2000

    Another film that makes you doubt the detective's reality, trading gothic mood for a puzzle.

  3. Film Vertigo Alfred Hitchcock · 1958

    The classic obsessive-investigator mystery whose spiral of delusion this film echoes.

More with the same DNA

Matched on the traits that make Shutter Island distinctive, across books and films.

  1. Book The Silent Patient Alex Michaelides · 2019

    Shares an unreliable narrator, psychological thrillers and mental health.

  2. Book Sharp Objects Gillian Flynn · 2006

    Shares an unreliable narrator, psychological thrillers and trauma and recovery.

  3. Book A Head Full of Ghosts Paul Tremblay · 2015

    Shares an unreliable narrator, psychological thrillers and New England.

  4. Book The Secret History Donna Tartt · 1992

    Shares an unreliable narrator, psychological thrillers and New England.

  5. Film Mystic River Clint Eastwood · 2003

    Shares New England, trauma and recovery and guilt and punishment.

  6. Film Psycho Alfred Hitchcock · 1960

    Shares psychological thrillers, mental health and a big twist.

  7. Book My Dark Vanessa Kate Elizabeth Russell · 2020

    Shares an unreliable narrator, New England and trauma and recovery.

  8. Film Gone Girl David Fincher · 2014

    Shares an unreliable narrator, psychological thrillers and a big twist.

Find it: Letterboxd · Wikipedia